Breaking News

Karoline Leavitt Ridiculed By Trump's Former Attorney With Her Most Brutal Nickname Yet

Pam Bondi's Cheap Looking Suit Is Giving SHEIN Instead Of Sophisticated

Usha Vance Confuses Ohio State White House Visit For Nursing Home In Bizarre Senior Citizen Sneakers

Candace Cameron Bure's Awful Orange Bronzer Feels Like A Thirst Trap For Trump

Pam Bondi & Dana Perino Duke It Out For Worst Disaster 'Do In Battle Of The Fox News Blondes

Trump & Elon's Bromance Is Wilting As New Leak Conveniently Reveals Donald Is In Charge

Michelle Trachtenberg's Cause Of Death Is Truly Tragic

Trump's Medical Records Hint At Real Reason He Wears So Much Makeup (& Expose An Insecurity)

2024-07-16

984 Read.

Hermes V Hermes: Turkey Bookshop Marks Win In Copyright Fight

A bookseller in Turkey notched a victory over a French luxury house in a copyright battle to be able to call itself Hermes, the shop's lawyer said Tuesday, hailing an infrequent win against a major brand.

An Ankara court ruling partially voided a decision by TurkPatent, Turkey's intellectual property authority, that prevented any brand other than Hermes Paris from using the name Hermes.

"Hermes is a god in Greek mythology who belongs to the cultural heritage of humanity. He should not be owned by a company. This is an important decision in that sense," the bookseller Umit Nar, whose shop is in the western city of Izmir, told AFP.

The shopkeeper pointed out that the deity is closely linked to the ancient history of Smyrna -- Izmir's old name -- on the Aegaen coast, where many Greek myths are set.

Hermes fashion house did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The court has not yet made its reasoning public, said the bookseller's lawyer, Hilmi Gullu, who added that the ruling was a "victory."

"Multinational firms like Hermes have an aggressive trademark registration policy, beyond their own industries. This verdict paves the way for saying no to these practices," Gullu said.

The case stretches back to December 2021, when the Turkish retailer sought to register a trademark for his 15-year-old bookshop.

A representative for the French company initiated legal proceedings against TurkPatent and took the case to court to ban the retailer from using "Hermes" in its brand name and any marketing materials.

Hermes fashion house emphasised the "similarity and risk of confusion" between the two names despite the different business sectors, arguing it is also active in publishing through its magazine.

"They would've been right if our sectors were similar, but that's absolutely not the case," said Nar.

The book dealer will still appeal the decision, as "the court has not ruled on the risk of confusion between the two brands in terms of audience and general impression," the lawyer said.

"I hope that this verdict will help set a precedent for cultural heritage and multinational firms," Nar said.